Comptroller Stringer Gives New York City A Grade Of “D” On M/WBE Procurement

October 1, 2014
UNVEILS NEW LETTER GRADING OF CITY AGENCY SPENDING WITH MINORITY & WOMEN-OWNED BUSINESS ENTERPRISES

NEW YORK, NY – More than two-thirds of City agencies earned “D”s or “F”s on Comptroller Scott M. Stringer’s inaugural letter grades assessing how well New York City government is procuring goods and services through minority and women-owned business enterprises (M/WBEs). The letter grades, outlined in the “Making the Grade” report released today, are intended as a diagnostic tool for agencies to improve performance and transparency in M/WBE spending, increase competition in City procurement and save taxpayer dollars.

“New York City spends more than $17 billion on goods and services each year, but less than four percent goes toward Minority and Women-Owned Business Enterprises,” Comptroller Stringer said. “When the City gets a ‘D’ for how well it is meeting its own goals, it’s clearly unacceptable. Growing the pie for M/WBE firms will be a key weapon in our battle against income inequality while increasing competition in procurement, driving down costs for taxpayers and creating jobs across all five boroughs.”

Local Law 1 of 2013 – which updated citywide goals for M/WBE procurement, broken down along ethnic and industry lines – provided the framework for the grading system. Thirty-one Mayoral Agencies and the Comptroller’s Office received grades, which are based on actual spending by City agencies. The following criteria were used to ascertain each Agency’s achievement against Local Law 1 goals:

  1. Determining the total Local Law 1-eligible spending by each City agency.
  2. Determining each agency’s actual spending across M/WBE categories and industries.
  3. Weighting results based on how agencies spend their budgets. For example, if an agency spends 50 percent of its budget on construction, 50 percent of its grade is based on M/WBE utilization in construction.
  4. Assigning a letter grade to the weighted score.

The citywide average for M/WBE spending as measured against Local Law 1 in FY14 was a grade of “D”. Just two agencies in the Comptroller’s report received a “B” grade: the Department of Cultural Affairs and the Landmarks Preservation Commission. Nine agencies received a “C”, including the Comptroller’s Office. Seventeen agencies received a grade of “D”, and four Mayoral Agencies received a failing grade. To see a full list of letter grades, please click here.

New York City has over 400,000 minority-owned firms and 300,000 women-owned firms, yet the M/WBE share of City procurement has dropped from a recent high of 5 percent in FY12 to only 3.9 percent in FY14. The Comptroller’s letter grades examine agency spending, not contracting, and excludes spending not subject to Local Law 1, such as human services.

“Improving our spending on M/WBEs is an economic and a social justice issue. It is unacceptable when not a single City agency can meet the standard set forth by our own laws. We need to take concrete steps to make sure that every company has an equal opportunity to compete to do business with the City. All agencies, and my office, must redouble efforts to help ensure our City’s economic future,” Stringer said.

Comptroller Stringer offered the following recommendations to improve Agency performance:

  • Expanding the Promise of Local Law 1: The “next generation” of the program should boost the number of agencies required to prepare utilization plans, offer enhanced training to M/WBE officers, and hold agencies accountable for spending further down their supply chain.
  • Increasing Transparency: Many City agencies have no specific information for or about M/WBEs on their websites. City agencies should have robust information available to help guide business owners through the procurement process.
  • Improving Data Entry: Agencies must redouble efforts to appropriately identify M/WBE contracts so existing spending can be tracked more effectively, thereby increasing the level of transparency and accountability.

To read the full report, please click here.

Para leer este comunicado en español, por favor haga clic aquí.

Comptroller Stringer would like to thank the members of his Advisory Council on Economic Growth through Diversity and Inclusion for their guidance in shaping the report released today.

Those members are:

Mr. Robert Abreu, Vice-President, Goldman Sachs

Mr. Vincent Alvarez, President, New York City Central Labor Council

Ms. Pilar Avila, New America Alliance

Ms. Deborah Axt and Mr. Javier Valdes, Co-Executive Directors, Make the Road New York

Ms. Neeta Bhasin, President and Chief Executive Officer, ASB Communications

Mr. Derrick Brown, Executive Director, National Gay and Lesbian Chamber of Commerce New York

Mr. José Calderón, President, Hispanic Federation

Ms. Alejandra Y. Castillo, Esq., National Director, Minority Business Development Agency

Mr. Louis J. Coletti, President and Chief Executive Officer, Building Trades Employers’ Association

The Reverend Jacques DeGraff, Minority Business Council, Executive Committee

Mr. Lloyd Douglas, Consultant, Lloyd Douglas Consulting Company

Dr. Hazel N. Dukes, President, NAACP New York State Conference

Dr. Marsha Firestone, President and Founder, Women Presidents’ Educational Organization – NY

Mr. José Garcia, Program Officer, Strong Local Economies, Surdna Foundation

Mr. Michael Garner, Chief Diversity Officer, Metropolitan Transportation Authority

Mr. Robert Greene, Special Advisor, National Association of Investment Companies

Mr. Jay Hershenson, Senior Vice Chancellor, City University of New York

Ms. Jill Houghton, Executive Director, U.S. Business Leadership Network

Mr. Gary LaBarbera, President, Building and Construction Trades Council of Greater New York

Mr. Hong Shing Lee, Executive Director, Chinese Manpower Project

Ms. Annie Minguez, Director of Community Relations, Good Shepherd Services

Mr. Marc Morial, President and Chief Executive Officer, National Urban League

Ms. Ana Oliveira, President and Chief Executive Officer, New York Women’s Foundation

Mr. Quentin Roach, Chief Procurement Officer, Merck & Co., Inc.

Ms. Lillian Rodriguez Lopez, Director, Latin Affairs, The Coca-Cola Company

Ms. Bazah Roohi, President and Founder, American Council of Minority Women

The Reverend Al Sharpton, National Action Network

Mr. Ruben Taborda, Chief Procurement Officer, Medical Devices, Johnson & Johnson

Ms. Elizabeth Velez, President, Velez Organization

Ms. Bonnie Wong, President, Asian Women in Business

Ms. Joset B. Wright-Lacy, President, National Minority Supplier Development Council

Mr. Charles Yoon, Partner, Yoon & Kim LLP

###

$242 billion
Aug
2022