Employer Violations Dashboard

1V59fytj0lQjHbQvnQ1jTxtuuyS-jLKI0_vcDmNwHN6E

Unfair Labor Practices

Last updated August 30, 2024

Unfair Labor Practices (“ULPs”) violate rights guaranteed by the National Labor Relations Act (“NLRA”). The NLRA is a federal law that grants employees the right to form or join unions and engage in protected concerted activities to address or improve working conditions. It also grants the National Labor Relations Board (“NLRB”), an independent federal agency, the authority to enforce these protections. When workers believe their employer has committed a ULP, the worker, the relevant union, or another representative may file a charge with their local NLRB regional office. The process may result in an Order from the NLRB to the employer directing the employer to end the illegal practice (“Board Order” or “BO”), a settlement between the employer and charging party (“Informal Settlement”), or the case being dismissed/withdrawn. The following charts include the employers with the largest number of alleged and adjudicated NLRA violations occurring in New York City worksites. They include both closed cases — where the cases ended in Board Orders or Informal Settlements — and open cases, where the outcome has yet to be determined.

There are many impediments that workers and their representatives face in filing ULPs and forming unions. Consistent with research showing the prevalence of interference in unionization efforts, such as a 2019 Economic Policy Institute study that found that ULPs occur in “41.5% of all union election campaigns,”[1] open cases are included in this dashboard, despite the outcomes not being fully concluded.

Closed Cases

Includes cases that were closed in 2020, 2021, 2022, and 2023 by Informal Settlements at New York City worksites. The number of violations for each employer are totals for the entire dataset, including employers that had multiple filings against them. The chart for 2020-2022 lists those employers with 50 or more workers in the unit and four or more NLRA violations. The 2023 charts include all NYC employers.

Unfair Labor Practice Violations for Cases Resulting in Informal Settlements, NYC Employers

2023

2020-2022

Includes cases that were closed in 2023 by Board Orders (“BO”) including: “Non-Compliance w/BO,” “Compliance w/BO,” and “Partial Compliance w/ BO," at New York City worksites.

Unfair Labor Practice Violations in 2023, Cases Closed via Board Orders, NYC Employers

Open Cases

These cases are charges filed by workers and unions and are still in process, as the outcomes of these cases have yet to be determined:

Open ULP Cases, More than 22 Alleged Violations, 2020 - 2023

Amazon is the only employer listed on this chart due to the difference in scale of open ULPs, in comparison to other employers.

Open ULP Cases, Between 9 and 22 Alleged Violations, 2020 - 2023

Includes cases that were opened in 2020, 2021, 2022, or 2023, and remain open as of August 2, 2024, where the worksite is located within New York City. The number of violations for each employer are totals for the entire dataset, containing some employers that had multiple cases filed against them. The charts list those employers with nine or more alleged ULP violations.

$242 billion
Aug
2022