NYC Comptroller Levine Releases New Report on Persistently High NYPD Overtime Costs, Proposes Reforms to Improve Oversight and Controls

New York, NY — The Office of New York City Comptroller Mark Levine today released A Framework for NYPD Structural Reform: An Analysis and Accountability Plan for Overtime Spending, Controls, and Risk. The NYC Comptroller’s Office estimates uniform spending at approximately $890 million for FY 2026 which would be the third-highest year on record, behind only FY 2024 and FY 2025. The report examines the driving causes of recurring uniformed overtime.   

“Overtime spending has been a clear cost the NYPD wants to rein in, especially as New York City seeks to reduce recurring expenses in light of projected budget gaps,” said City Comptroller Mark Levine. “Overtime should be used when absolutely necessary to enable police officers to keep communities safe. This report offers an assessment for how the department can better plan for events that continue to drive up overtime costs, and highlights the potential for structural savings that can better equip the City for an uncertain economic future.” 

The Comptroller’s Office found that NYPD uniformed overtime is not driven solely by unexpected events. Substantial overtime remains concentrated in foreseeable deployments, especially planned events – parades, details, and quality of life initiatives. This category accounted for $26.4 million, or 58% of events/detail spending from October to December 2025 alone. 

The report also shows that recurring and foreseeable deployments should be subject to staffing plans, scheduling discipline, documented approval criteria, and after-action review rather than routine overtime reliance.  

While the Mayor’s FY 2027 Executive Budget includes additional funding to address chronic underbudgeting, the Comptroller’s report finds that it still does not fully cover projected overtime spending.  

As the nation’s largest police department continues to work to reduce overtime spending, the report proposes comprehensive reforms to help reduce predictable costs while balancing public safety, including: 

• Improve Planning for Events, Reduce Repeat Outliers. The NYPD’s formal written policy should require written pre-event staffing plans and post-event reviews, identify events that reliably generate overtime, and require written mitigation plans for repeat outliers, such as rotation, schedule redesign, or staffing changes, rather than recurring approvals. 

• Manage Risks from Excessive Hours. Excessive hours increase the likelihood of errors, injuries, and other negative outcomes. The NYPD should establish minimum rest periods following mandatory overtime and extended tours, and should also establish maximum consecutive hours and days with overtime. The NYPD should also require quarterly compliance reporting and corrective action for repeat noncompliance. 

• Strengthen Accountability for Recurring Overages. The NYPD’s written policy should require written corrective action plans for commands that exceed thresholds for two consecutive quarters or in three quarters within a fiscal year, including root-cause analysis, specific operational changes, responsible personnel, and a timeline for compliance, followed by reduction target assessments in the following two quarters. 

• Build a Thoughtful Compliance Function. This should include formal repeat-overage escalation pathways requiring senior written review, as well as annual summaries of audit findings. Oversight should be paired with regular reporting that identifies commands with the highest overtime, fastest growth, and repeated overage explanations, and includes other standardized data collection.  

You can read the full report by clicking here: https://comptroller.nyc.gov/reports/a-framework-for-structural-nypd-overtime-reform 

###